This morning I posted the following comment on our Facebook page:
“The saying “God only gives special children to special people” is whack. Please stop saying it. #SpecialNeedsProTip :-)”
Boy, oh boy, I had no idea how much Facebook controversy that status update would cause.
Most people agreed with me, but a few didn’t. In fact, one person actually left a comment saying, “I used to love this page ….[but] I really want to cuss you all out ..” LOL…Wow! You want to “cuss me out” because of a Facebook status update? Yikes!
*hugs*
I realize that a few folks may have misinterpreted / misunderstood the meaning behind my comment so I thought I would write a blog post explaining the meaning behind my Facebook comment this morning.
Does God really only give “special kids” to “special parents?” The answer is both yes…and no. In other words, I think that statement is both whack…and un-whack.
Let me explain.
Before I begin, please allow me to make a few simple observations so we’re all on the same page: When someone says this statement what they typically mean is that God only gives children with a disability “(special kids”) to great parents (“special parents”) or parents that are somehow able to raise a child with a disability better than the all the other parents in the world. (I also know this is “filler talk” because they don’t know what else to say, which is ok. I”m not saying I’m offended by the comment, or that it’s a hurtful thing to say…I’m simply saying the comment is “whack”….or untrue.)
One other point of reference; good parents love their children and do everything within their ability to help them grow, develop, and become the people God created them to be. They don’t harm, abuse, or murder them.
Ok, here we go.
It’s no secret that a mother’s womb is the most dangerous place in the world for a child with Down syndrome. More than 90% of children suspected to have Down syndrome in the womb are aborted…for no other reason than that they may have Down syndrome. That’s tragic…and whack! Good parents (special parents) don’t murder their children…regardless of if they have Down syndrome (“special kids”) or not. This point alone shows us that the statement “God only gives special children to special parents” is indeed, whack.
In fact, based on the facts you’d have to say;
“God seems to give more children with Down syndrome to parents who are going to murder them.”
or
“The odds are that if you are pregnant, and based on prenatal testing find out that your child may have Down syndrome, you will be a bad parent…not a good (or “special”) one. (Remember, “good” or “special” parents don’t murder their children.)
If you are raising a child with Down syndrome, you are in the minority, not the majority of good (aka: “special”) parents. Most parents of children with Down syndrome abort them. In other words; most parents of “special kids” (kids with Down syndrome) aren’t “special” (or good) parents, in fact by definition, they are bad parents.
One more time: good parents don’t murder their children.
I’ve talked to more single mothers than I want to count whose husband divorced or abandoned them after their “special” child was born. Divorcing your wife or abandoning your family isn’t something a “special” (good) parent does….rather something a whack (bad) parent. By definition not being there for your wife and child makes you a “bad” parent (I think we can all agree that abandoning your child certainly doesn’t make you a “good” parent.)
I don’t know what I would feel like if I didn’t have a son with Down syndrome and someone told me “God only gives special kids to special families.” Should I feel hurt? Should I feel offended that that person (or God!) doesn’t think I’m a “special” (aka: good) parent? Also is the reward for being a “good” (aka: special) parent, having a child with Down syndrome? If so, and I didn’t have one, should I keep trying to be a better (aka: more special) parent until God deems me “special” enough that He would give me one of these “special” children?
None of these things make much sense to me…and in fact, they seem a little “whack” to be honest. 🙂
By the way, I know TONS of “special” (aka: good) parents that don’t have a “special child” (aka: child with a disability.) So if God truly does only give “special kids” to “special parents” he must also give “non-special” (typically developing) kids to “special parents” (aka: good parents) also.
To be fair I actually think this statement at its core is true. It is very much true that God gives “special children” to “special people.” But it has nothing to do with a child having a disability, or a parent raising a child that does.
Let me explain;
All people have infinite value and worth not because they are born with a disability, or parenting a child who does. Genesis 1:27 tells us that;
“God created humankind in his own image..”
In other words, every person on this planet is “special” because each and every person on this planet is created in the image of the most “special” Person that has ever existed, God.
Also in Psalm 139:13-14 we’re told that;
“For you created my inmost being; you knit me together in my mother’s womb. I praise you because I am fearfully and wonderfully made; your works are wonderful”
In other words, God created every person on this planet, and everything He creates is “wonderful” or “special”…not because they were born with a disability, or parenting a child who does…but simply because God made them!
That’s pretty awesome!
The bottom line is God does give special children to special people.
All parents are special and all children are special. Period.
Having a child with special needs doesn’t make you any more special than any other parent raising any other kid, sorry. I know some parents like to use their child having a disability as a way to say they are “more” special than other parents, but it’s simply not true.
Please stop.
Just be a parent. A parent raising a child with a disability. You don’t have to be “more special” than other parents. You are as special as any parent can be… just because you are made by God, and in the Image of God. You (or your child) can’t be any more special than that.
While it’s true that are parents are “special” since every parent is created in the image of God, not all parents are “good” parent. As I mentioned above, some parents abandon their children and their family, some parents murder their children, some parents never teach their children about God, and many other parents pursue their careers more than they pursue a relationship with their child. This isn’t being a “special” (aka: good) parent…it’s being a “whack” (aka: bad) one.
If you really want to be a “special parent” (aka: a good one) put in to action some of the things good parents do, and teach them how to grow up be a “special” man or women. Good parents are rare these days. There are no magic time machines, and you only have one shot to be a game changing one. Make it count!
I believe every parent is a “special parent” (created in the image of God) and has the ability to be a “special parent” (aka: a good parent) as well. No matter your background, upbringing, or what kind of parents you had growing up. Every child (special needs or typical) has his or her own set of challenges.
Parenting isn’t easy….but it’s awesome, and there’s nothing else like it.
Lastly, if you are a parent of a child with Down syndrome (or any other disability) I want to encourage you to have tons and tons of grace with people. Most people have no idea what to say and I totally get that. (By the way, if that’s you here’s a few suggestions.) I would never want to make anyone feel awkward, or discourage them from having the courage to say something (even if what they are saying isn’t necessarily true.) So lighten up, give people the benefit of the doubt, and always assume the best about people.
I feel a similar tension about people saying the word “retarded.” I hear people saying that word all the time, and most of time they have no idea why it’s offensive, or why they should stop saying it. I usually know the person and their heart / motive isn’t to be offensive or hurtful, so I don’t say anything simply because I don’t want to make them feel bad, especially if it’s in front of a group of people. It’s a weird tension that I’m still trying to figure out myself. (By the way, I’d be interested to hear how you handle this in the comments.).if you see me out a
Oh, and if you see me out and about and happen to tell me that “God only gives special kids to special people” don’t worry…you won’t offend me or hurt my feelings. In fact, I’ll probably just smile and say “I don’t know about that.” (And maybe email this post to you.)….Just don’t tell me that “all kids with Down syndrome are angels.” 🙂
I’d love to hear your thoughts on all of this in the comments below. Just please don’t “cuss me out” …because that wouldn’t be very “special”…or nice! 🙂
Bitty and Beau’s Coffee is an amazing nationwide coffee shop chain that is much more… Read More
Ever since we took Noah to his very first dance party many years ago, this… Read More
One of the first things our OB/GYN told us after we received our son's Down… Read More
Before the pandemic, my wife and I were both members at Orange Theory Fitness (and… Read More
As the parent of a child with Down syndrome, I have wondered if people with… Read More
I Love Being His Coach! After 18 plus months off due to COVID-19, Noah started… Read More
View Comments
Agreed. I do not like this saying and for (most of) the reasons you have just explained. Thank you for taking the time to explain them . LOL , because I don't have the patience to do it myself.
No problem Mel, Thanks for your comment.
Whoa.
I missed the controversy, but this is an excellent post. (Perhaps even an extra special one. ;) ) Thanks for sharing, Rick. Really good stuff to chew on here.
Thanks Jamie. :)
I also hate that saying, and appreciate your comments....one thing you didn't mention is the number of children with Down's Syndrome or other problems that are in dysfunctional families.....I've seen those too. Another saying I hate is when people say to me, "Those children are so sweet and loving." I am a paramedic, called to Camp Sunnyside and see a wide continuum. It is my granddaughter who has Down's Syndrome, and we had no idea. She is now 2 years old with a wonderful, gentle older brother and a brand new 2 week old baby brother. We love her dearly. Thanks for your website.
Thanks Becky! I've never heard of Camp Sunnyside but it sounds awesome! Tell me more about it please. :)
I recently posted about the same thing!
http://themommyonamission.blogspot.com/2013/06/another-lesson-from-cart-what-not-to-say.html
Awesome! Keep up the great work!
By the way, feel free to link to this post if you'd like! You're more than welcome to.
I have a daughter born with downs, I've heard that statement more times than i can count. She is the light of mine and my husband's lives, but I still feel it would be that way whether she has downs or not. I don't feel any "more special" than any other parent of any "normal" child. I love being a parent to her, and in 7 more weeks to her little sister. :)
I also don't agree with using the word "retarded" and most people don't use it around me. I'm not sure if it's because they know I might get offended because my daughter has downs or if they are just as against that word as I am.
Thanks for the comment, and I agree with you!
Do you guys have any other children?
I completely agree with most of what you say and I am not a fan of that line either. In fact, I wrote a post on it last year that your sweet wife was nice enough to comment on. :-) I actually have different reasons for disliking it but in the end it comes down to not believing that I'm any more special than anyone else. And there are plenty of parents of kids with disabilities that aren't really doing a fantastic job, even if they don't abort them or even leave them - way too many kids with disabilities (and without!) are neglected or abused by some pretty lousy parents. I certainly don't think anyone would consider them special because they have a child with a disability. If you are interested on my take on this oft-misused phrase, here is my link: http://ohdudaday.blogspot.com/2012/08/im-not-special-and-neither-is-my-kid.html
Thanks for sharing your thoughts as always!
Thanks for your comment and for jumping in! (And for sharing your link!)
How many children do you have by the way?
We have two boys. An almost 9 year old and a just turned 5 year old who happens to have DS. We love them both but don't think they - or we - are any more special than anyone else! :-)
Love it! I bet you guys have a house full of fun!
We can't wait for Noah to meet his little brother that's due early next year!
What sort of things does your five year old with Down syndrome like to do for fun?
Well written. I understood your view this morning and like your follow-up explanation. I do however appreciate the sentiment of the person who wrote the message: it was meant in solidarity and when there are people who vilify special needs children (see Ontario last week), it is heartwarming to see such lovely support.
I agree, the post (and the Facebook comment) actually didn't really have anything to do with that note the people wrote on the napkin. I've been saying that statement is "whack" for a while now. :)
Thanks for your comment.
I enjoy your insight on things. I have one question....why do some people that have a disabled child say "I wouldn't change my child if I could." I have a deaf family member & if I could make her a hearing child I would. Keep up the good work & hug Noah for me.
Thanks!
Here's a couple of posts I would use to answer your question:
http://noahsdad.com/blessing/
http://noahsdad.com/down-syndrome-watching-tv/
I missed the controversy as well
But I too have always disliked that statement!! Great points!
Thanks!
"Most parents of children with Down syndrome abort them." That is false. Traditionally, most parents have not done pre-natal testing. Something like 95% have not. Now that may change with the simpler tests, but we don't have statistics about how people make decisions with those tests.
"I’ve talked to more single mothers than I want to count whose husband divorced their family after their “special” child was born. " That may be your experience, but that's not typical of our community. The divorce rate for parents of children with Down syndrome has been shown to be lower than that for parents of typical kids and parents of special needs kids of other types.
In general, I agree with your post - I hate that special parent thing. Like most things that get circulated about special needs parents on FB, it's unbearably trite. But what I dislike more than trite is bad information, which is what you've put here.
Most parents who learn, through testing, that their child has Ds do abort... More than 90%. I don't know where you live, but these are the facts in the US.
Additionally, a married couple with a child with special needs have more than a 40% greater chance to divorce than the next couple; and since more than 50% of marriages end in divorce to begin with, I would say those are pretty significant odds against a couple who has a child with Ds staying together.
Anne,
Sadly that statistic isn't "false." (I wish it were.)
And I wasn't saying that having a child with Down syndrome causes more couples to be divorced (in fact the studies show it actually decreases divorce rates.) What I was saying is, if God "only" gave special kids to "special" parents, than none of those parents would abandon their children (or their spouse.) The divorce rate would be zero if that statement was really true.
Hope that makes sense, and thanks for your comment.
Sadly I am one of those statistics. I learned that my child had Down syndrome while early in my pregancy. I became a single mom because I refused to abort. I have raised all three of my boys as a single mom. Do I feel like a "special parent".....no I'm just a mom trying to raise good men. Am I a good parent....you better believe it. Has my youngest child made me a "better" parent....yes.
Jan,
I'm sorry for what you have to go through, and I'm sorry that it feels like you are doing this alone. Parenting is hard. Single parenting is even harder.
Are you plugged in to a good church there where you live with lots of great friends who come along beside you?
There is a huge difference between saying "most people who have a child with Down syndrome abort him/her" and saying "most people who have a prenatal diagnosis of Down syndrome abort the child". I agree with the latter. But my point is that the vast majority of pregnant women have not traditionally done amnio to get the prenatal diagnosis. As such, your statement is false. And, if you don't understand the math, I'd ask you to not publish statistical info.
I saw that post earlier and I'm so glad you wrote this! Way to clarify, good sir! Nicely put!
All children are gifts given to the world!
These little Gifts can come in unexpected packages, but I believe that each child is created by God specifically for their family (biological/adopted/the people who LOVE them) I think being a parent is special honor, one that I hope I will soon be given!!!
♥♥♥
ps> I know that might read as super sappy (I'm not incredibly good at wording these kind of things) :-)
I think you did a great job! Thanks for your comment.